Sunday, October 22, 2006

Proof #5: Prophets need to eat to live

And We did not give them bodies that ate no food, nor were they to live for ever. (21:9) more translations

This verse makes the following statements about prophets:

  • They cannot survive without food.
  • They do not live for ever.
It is mentioned in 5:76 that Jesus used to eat food. Since he does not eat anymore, so according to this verse, his corporeal existence must have terminated, i.e. he has died.

It further states that Prophets do not live for ever. “Live for ever” should not be taken too literally as the concept of eternity is abstract and unfathomable. An argument of this nature that limits itself only to negation of eternity carries very little meaning. Come eternity, no one will be around to check if anyone still survives. One way to understand this is to ask the question if a million year lifespan would run afoul of this verse? Or would a thousand? Clearly both would. The fact is that any lifespan that could be classed as unnatural or aberrational in its extent is disallowed here. If Jesus is still alive, it would make him some 2000 years old! Needless to say, that is unnatural for an ordinary person as well as a prophet.

Next Proof>

1 comment:

royalravian said...

All prophets live and they are not dead as shaheed remains always alive in the same sense prophets are all alive but we cannot imagine their lives. They will be alive forever hereafter.
Holy Prophet(S.A.W.W) said, I listen your darood which you have sent upon me.
How can we say that Naozbillah prophet is dead.
Please don't think that prophet is dead, just quiet from such thinking...!!